September 18,09 - Presentations Cont. and a Bit of Philosophy

Filed under: by:

You can’t move forward when you are looking behind. You can’t get stuck on one theory. Sometimes great ideas get ignored. Don’t get caught in a paradigm, a secure argument and that sums up the world.
We don’t work on Learning Theories anymore, but on theories of learning.
You have to just start piecing the world together. You must keep on reading even after we graduate.
Bro. Gibbons philosophy on science, Tech., and how it all fits together:
I can’t buy into the idea that we continue to learn throughout eternity. We do learn in eternity but eventually we reach the peak and there isn’t another peak. The scriptures and several modern prophets have clearly said that God does not continue to learn. His increase is due to glory, the rearing of his children into eternity. That is his increase, not additional learning. Joseph Fielding Smith makes this very clear in Doctrines of Salvations, Vol 1, chapter 1.
The empirical processes of science don’t fit well in social science because the human element doesn’t work well with that system. Social scientists have to go about things in a slightly different well. This is where control group research. Philosophers don’t fit into this system, they stand apart from all this.
There’s almost a hierarchy of learning types, physics at top and others down the snobbish scale till you get to near the bottom, and that’s where IPT and sits. This is partly because we use the word technology and don’t have the word science in it.
Many fields are actually technologist but call themselves scientists and this is to give more credibility to their field.
Objectivity is a myth.
One of the dangers of institutionalized science is that you can buy the study you want to back up what you want it to back up. Corporations (and I would add governments) can do this. Science working and bringing forth good knowledge must come from truthful scientists. – I think this is really is true and I use global warming as an example!
Design Based Research. Supposed to be a Very good class and concept we should think about/ work for. I think I’d like to check this out.
A lot of these theories are a continuation of non-sense. It wasn’t right to begin with and yet people keep playing with it for decades and so the field doesn’t move forth
End of Philosophy
Mirrored Neurons – Same neurons fire when you watch an action and when to perform that same action.
Not sure the role that all this plays into life and everything yet.
Design implications of this: Dynamic visualizations – watching a video or something like that when you try to understand a concept instead of just looking at static visualizations such as pictures. In other words, dynamic vis. You watch the moon switch from phase to phase instead of looking at pictures of different phases of the moon. Sometimes dynamic work better and sometimes not.
Bro. Gibbons philosophy again/more on mirrored neurons:
Instructional designers, because they have been so interested in being recognized by science, they ignore some important ideas like mirrored neurons.
Example does a lot to help teach – maybe because of Mirrored Neurons.
Could you teach a dance or music skill without saying a word, just at modeling? –Possibly so and that could be because of mirror neurons.
Some people seem to lack the ability to mirror others.
Pornography could be so dangerous because of mirrored neurons!
Everyone is their own instructional designer, we just don’t know it!
If God tells us to obey, then we can, even if we think we can’t.
Mirrored neurons could be the thing that helps us connect with other people, to have empathy, etc.
This is why movies with lots of violence are probably not good for us.
I have to say, that I don’t agree with everything in this philosophy, but I think there is a lot of good stuff in what was said and I’d like to get more information about much of what was said, esp. mirror neurons.

September 16, 09 - My Thoughts from Presentations

Filed under: by:

Cognitive apprenticeship (instructional Theory) - Only in modern society have we gone away from apprenticeship style learning. We aren’t learning so much the actions any more but the cognitive actions, the meta-cognition actions. Four areas of importance:
1. content – subject matter (4 kinds, one is meta cognition)
2. Sociology – who is there when learning takes place and what are their roles. (5 things)
3. Sequence – order in which things happen in instruction is not random, there is a reason. (4 things)
4. Method of Instruction – (6 different methods – one of the methods is not lecture, its apprenticeship)
Voice Thread – a great way to add instruction for something.
Increasingly Complex Micro Worlds (ICM)- a sequence of mini environments or worlds that increasing become more complex. Students learn one little task and then is given a new task to learn which incorporates previous tasks and new tasks.
You can see how your own skills factor into the more complex actions when you have a more advanced person who you can watch do the more complex things.
Tennis ball shooting machine – focusing on just the swing before you worry about placement of the ball in the court.
Undo button – allows exploration of computers and such. Starts small.
Designers need to consider the right entry points for the learner. Also consider how to make that person feel “safe.” Consider intermediate challenges that are obtainable to help build confidence.
Allow the practice of certain skills in isolation thus you don’t have two master 2 skills at first. Try to identify problems with the learner’s concepts early on.
This life is a mircoworld (missionary life to family to eternal family) of how it eternal life is.- what is temporal is spiritual, the principles are the same in either world.
Mircoworld is becoming much more into the cognitive domain.
Also, if one considers spiritual development, first we focus on family, then neighborhood, then community, nation, world and finally many worlds. This is an example of increasingly complex mircoworlds.
Gagne’s Taxonomy
5 major categories, learning conditions optimal for one might be different for another.
Gagne’s 9 Events – an instructional theory
These are learning events (9 of them)
We need to be deliberate in how we organize things
You could rearrange these steps if we need to. But we should probably do it with reason and not just because.

September 14, 09 - Presentations and Thoughts on Technologists

Filed under: by:

I enjoyed learning about Meta cognition. I was a little familiar with the concept already but I’d never really thought about all the implications of it. My roommate and I actually had a long conversation about it and as we spoke we tried to apply the principles of meta cognition. We were both amazed at how much more you can learn and the greater understanding it gives you, esp. when trying to understand what another person thinks about a specific subject.
I’ve also been thinking more about the differences between a scientist and a technologist. I considered myself a scientist most of my life (until I decided to study history in college) but I think I was really a technologist. I have built all kinds of things over the years including explosives and robots. I always based my ideas on scientific knowledge that I had but I also added things that I thought would make my design work better. At the time I couldn’t tell you why I thought the things I added would help in terms of science, but just had a hunch. Often, if I turned out to be right I would investigate further and discover the scientific principle behind why it worked. In all of this I just saw myself as a scientist. I realize now that what I was doing was playing the two different parts. Most of what I did was as a technologist by designing and building things and in so doing (by process of innovation) produced “new” knowledge such as “adding this makes my design work better.” I would then play the role of the scientist and try and figure out why that worked. However, I spent far less time trying to figure out why it worked than I did just designing and building.
When I recognized this difference, I realized that the people who I usually called “inventors” were in fact technologists. Before this, I had always just thought of inventors as some type of scientists. Our culture encourages this idea too. In the popular film “Back to the Future,” one of the main characters, “Doc” Brown, is always referred to as a scientist, even by himself. But I now see that he was really a technologist who used his knowledge of science to invent. Meeting a “crazy, wide-eyed” technologist just doesn’t have the same ring to it! This, of course, goes back to why the word science is found in lots of different places where another word properly belongs.

September 11, 09 - Learning Theory vs Theores of Learning

Filed under: by:

I’m still pretty confused about all the terminology but hopefully that will come together soon, right? I think some type of graphic that showed how all these terms come together and where they fit in comparison to one another would be helpful for me and probably many other people in the class as well.
I like the idea of “theories of learning” as opposed to “learning theory.” In my foundations class we’ve been studying lots of learning theories and one of the things we were supposed to think about as we read them was which one we liked, which one we felt we came closest to fitting into. After reading about all those theories, I didn’t like any of them! I thought they all had gaping holes. Each one had a point or two that I liked, but none came even close to getting everything right. While I think there is an explanation that brings all learning together, I don’t think we even begin to describe it. I feel much better about the approach of theories of learning. Here’s is a graphic demonstrating my understanding of the difference between these 3 approaches:

In this diagram we see that Learning Theories are trying to define everything, the whole pie. Theories of learning aren’t concerned with the whole picture; it may not even be a pie! Instead, they focus on different aspects of learning or different sections of the pie.
I think that the different areas of which theories learning focus, who, when, what where, why, how is very insightful. I think that is a good way of looking at learning and I believe each has a part to play. I never thought about how much “where” has to do with learning. I mean I knew it’s not good to study in a place with lots of distractions, for example, but I never thought about arranging virtually every aspect area you in such a manner as to promote learning. It’s amazing.
The other aspect of chapter 5 that stood out to me was the section about stories as a part of learning. I think this play a big part in my personal learning. Any story that I’m told I can remember with incredible ease but if you give me a detailed list of information or a list of numbers, I can’t remember it. I think this is why studying history was so easy for me but sometimes science could give me a hard time.

September 9, 09 - A Plethora of Terms

Filed under: by:

I have to say, I’m pretty overwhelmed by all the terms and relationships between the terms that we discussed today. While I struggle with the language, I think I understand, at least at the rudimentary level, what most of it means. The reason for looking at instructional design (and really, this holds true in any design) using the architecture we’ve discussed to is so that you can create better designs, identify reoccurring problems and solutions to those problems, and discuss various aspects of design with more ease.

I think I might have a basic understanding of Instructional theory, instructional design theory and the interplay between these two areas. From what I understand, instructional theory is concerned with the presentation of the instruction. It’s focused on the structure of the information presented. Instructional design theory concerns itself with how to build that structure. Thus, instructional design theory, while separate, works within instructional theory.
I like the idea of looking at design from a layers method instead of a process. I think that is how I naturally go about designing something. Even without this background in design, if I were to design a house, I think I would design it based on function. Looking at the different aspects of the house and what I want it to do just makes sense to me. I wonder why anyone would go through a purely process-driven approach. Using a layers approach and the design language, designers can specify problems they routinely encounter in a particular area and be able to more easily discuss these problems with others thus generating multiple solutions that can be employed. This, with other factors, allows that layer of design to advance much quicker than before. Another thing I like about this idea of layers is that every time you go to design something, you don’t have to start from scratch. Using different designs of a particular layer in combination with other layers could create a whole new design. Granted, each layer would probably require some modifications in order to make the overall design work, but at least you didn’t have to re-invent the wheel! You could then spend more time on another area of your design that is in need of more attention but which was in past designs had been ignored because of time constraints.

I am a little less clear about the design layers discussed for instructional design. The content layer seems to make sense. Taking the content, the abstract ideas and breaking into units is how I always approached teaching history: Egypt, Mesopotamia, Greece, and Rome. However, the farther down the list of layers I go, the less I understand the concepts associated with the layers. Perhaps this is due, in part, to the fact that these are areas that have largely been ignored by theorists. I think that as I become more involved in instructional design through this class and through designing instruction for the IPT 286 class I’m teaching, these layers of design will begin to gain more meaning for me.

September 4, 09 - Conversation as a Metaphor

Filed under: by:

I really enjoyed this chapter on conversation as a metaphor in instruction. I really think that there is significance to the ideas presented. There were a few things that stood out to me.
The argument was made that conversation takes place across different media and through time. This, of course, is absolutely true and I agree that learning can also be done over various media and over time, but is that really the best way to do it? True, it’s still conversation but is the conversation as valuable (important, meaningful, etc) as medium and time change and increase? Is there something lost when f2f conversation is lost? If there is no loss, why do people use video phones? While conversation may still take place as medium changes and time increases, is there something that gets lost, something valuable in instruction. Obviously if there is simply no other way to converse, say because the 2 people are in different countries these options are great and better alternatives’ than what’s been done in the past. But if f2f is possible, at least some of the time, would there be more value in conversing or instructing in this manner? I can’t say why but instinctively feel there is a greater value.
Page nine contained one statement: “in many cases, we have come to accept as a standard of adequate instruction the presentation of information without relevant responding and engagement by the learner.” I believe God is the perfect example when it comes to designing learning and He, like all designers, has certain resources with which He can work but makes the best instruction he that can be with what there is to work with. Take a look at the scriptures, a form of instruction that would seem to prevent conversation between the learner, man and the instructor, God. We’ve been told in the church numerous times to ponder the scriptures. Why? Because this is an opportunity for us to “respond” to what God has written. A conversation takes place. The conversation continues in another medium as the Spirit places impressions, thoughts, etc in our minds as we ponder. If we choose to ponder on the thoughts the spirit has brought us, we are again engaging in the responding process. As this cycle continues, we converse with God using different mediums but conversation takes place and instruction is given – spiritual learning occurs! Full conversational learning with God almost necessitates modern revelation!
One final statement provoked a great deal of thought for me: “some instructional theorists define instruction in terms of the ability to test what a person has learned: they say that if there’s no test, it’s not instruction. This would seem to disqualify conversations as instruction, because we seldom give tests on the outcomes of conversations.” I disagree with the argument these theorist make, there ARE tests in conversation, even casual ones. Perhaps they do not occur as frequently as they should, but they do occur. We often check to make sure others understand what we’ve said when we talk. How often have you heard the phrase “you know what I mean” in conversation? This is an attempt, granted a poor one, to test a person’s comprehension of what the other has said. Occasionally, people will have a misunderstanding, somehow the people involved have discovered that one person has not “learned” what the other intended them too. In order for this to happen, some type of test must have been administered.

September 2, 09 - Two Chapters and an Interview

Filed under: by:

Reading these two chapters has been an eye opening experience. I went through the education program at BYU, did student teaching and worked in the schools for a couple of years without ever really understanding the principles of technology instruction discussed in these chapters. I’ve never felt as though I was a successful teacher and I think I now understand why. At times it seemed I was a really good teacher and at other times I felt very ineffective. I now see that the times when I felt I was doing well were times I was successfully directing the natural energy of the students and the times when I failed I was failing to successfully re-direct that energy. I used the same methods but couldn’t understand why I got different results. The problem, it seems, with my attempts to direct the students’ natural learning was that I was not evaluating why there was a loss in their desire to learn. If I had recognized the differences I could have chosen a more effective way to re-direct their learning energies.

I am also fascinated by with the distinction these chapters drew between technology and science. Most of my life I have thought of myself as a scientist and always thought the realm that truly belongs to technology of being within the sphere of science. I now understand that while one affects the other, they are 2 distinct disciplines working on different problems.

I interviewed my friend Mike who builds computers. The very nature of building computers requires one to design. Lots of different criteria go into designing a computer, such as what will it be used for. Resources that come into play include how much is the client willing to spend and what products are available (RAM, motherboards, CPU’s, etc). With an idea of what the machine has to do and price range in site, Mike said he starts with selecting a motherboard and a case to fit it. At first glance, this seems like a natural place to start as these components are essentially the physical foundation of the computer. However, I asked if it wouldn’t make more sense to pick out the CPU first so as to make sure it will have the power to do what his client wants it to do. With the CPU picked out, you could then select a motherboard to fit it instead of the other way around. Enter around aspect of design: bias. Mike said he picks the motherboard first because he prefers a specific kind of socket (the part of the motherboard which allows the CPU to interface with the board). For better or for worse, bias probably always plays a part in design. And why not (to a point), after all, there are no “right answers” in design. Once the motherboard and processor are chosen, he picks out the RAM which will work with the motherboard, trying to get the fastest he can but keeping in mind what the client needs – to try and save them money if they’re price conscious – or the fastest, best RAM he can (within the overall budget) if the client wants the best machine they can get for a particular price. Using similar criteria, he picks out a graphics card, hard drives, optical drives, and other peripherals. Then it’s time to choose the power supply. This choice is dictated by how much power the machine will need to run all of its components. Finally, Mike says the most important thing to remember when designing a computer is to remember what it will be used for. Resources may affect this, but if you forget the end goal the design will suffer.