September 4, 09 - Conversation as a Metaphor

Filed under: by:

I really enjoyed this chapter on conversation as a metaphor in instruction. I really think that there is significance to the ideas presented. There were a few things that stood out to me.
The argument was made that conversation takes place across different media and through time. This, of course, is absolutely true and I agree that learning can also be done over various media and over time, but is that really the best way to do it? True, it’s still conversation but is the conversation as valuable (important, meaningful, etc) as medium and time change and increase? Is there something lost when f2f conversation is lost? If there is no loss, why do people use video phones? While conversation may still take place as medium changes and time increases, is there something that gets lost, something valuable in instruction. Obviously if there is simply no other way to converse, say because the 2 people are in different countries these options are great and better alternatives’ than what’s been done in the past. But if f2f is possible, at least some of the time, would there be more value in conversing or instructing in this manner? I can’t say why but instinctively feel there is a greater value.
Page nine contained one statement: “in many cases, we have come to accept as a standard of adequate instruction the presentation of information without relevant responding and engagement by the learner.” I believe God is the perfect example when it comes to designing learning and He, like all designers, has certain resources with which He can work but makes the best instruction he that can be with what there is to work with. Take a look at the scriptures, a form of instruction that would seem to prevent conversation between the learner, man and the instructor, God. We’ve been told in the church numerous times to ponder the scriptures. Why? Because this is an opportunity for us to “respond” to what God has written. A conversation takes place. The conversation continues in another medium as the Spirit places impressions, thoughts, etc in our minds as we ponder. If we choose to ponder on the thoughts the spirit has brought us, we are again engaging in the responding process. As this cycle continues, we converse with God using different mediums but conversation takes place and instruction is given – spiritual learning occurs! Full conversational learning with God almost necessitates modern revelation!
One final statement provoked a great deal of thought for me: “some instructional theorists define instruction in terms of the ability to test what a person has learned: they say that if there’s no test, it’s not instruction. This would seem to disqualify conversations as instruction, because we seldom give tests on the outcomes of conversations.” I disagree with the argument these theorist make, there ARE tests in conversation, even casual ones. Perhaps they do not occur as frequently as they should, but they do occur. We often check to make sure others understand what we’ve said when we talk. How often have you heard the phrase “you know what I mean” in conversation? This is an attempt, granted a poor one, to test a person’s comprehension of what the other has said. Occasionally, people will have a misunderstanding, somehow the people involved have discovered that one person has not “learned” what the other intended them too. In order for this to happen, some type of test must have been administered.

0 comments: