August 31, 09 - IDEO

Filed under: by:

I was really impressed by Ideo’s mindset which they used to come up with creative solutions. Instead of trying to become experts on a particular device or situation (such as the shopping cart) by sitting in a cubicle and thinking about it, they went out and talked to the real experts, people who had experience with different aspects of shopping carts. The group brainstorming was also unique. I loved the fact that crazy ideas were encouraged because it would allow more jump off points for designs that would work. In connection with crazy ideas was the guideline, “don’t criticize an idea.” I imagine this would be very difficult to do. I can see the potential this method has for producing new ideas that can eventually be adapted into something that will work. Finally, by having group members choose which designs they like as opposed to having just the boss pick what he likes, I believe better results were achieved. When just one or a few people make decisions like which design to go with, you are losing so much valuable experience that the other group members could contribute. Some group members might see advantages to a particular design that the boss didn’t see and by involving the group the best designs are less likely to be missed.

As for the final product, I think the team had some good ideas and had flushed out what goals needed to be achieved, but the cart still needed more work. I’m sure the very limited time frame within which the team had to work contributed to this. The argument was made that by removing the one big basket and creating just a frame for small baskets to sit in, people would be less likely to steal the cart because there would be no basket. But people could just as easily sneak the small baskets out and have a complete cart. Another problem with using just small baskets is that the total available volume to hold your items would be greatly reduced. Reducing the volume will likely reduce how much customers would buy. If anything, the cart should have more volume so people can put more items inside to buy. The hooks from which you could hang your bags also had drawbacks. If the bags ripped the contents would spill onto the floor. There were also a limited number of hooks which would again cause reduced volume which in turn would encourage the customer to buy less. One thing I did like about the design was the fact that the big bulky cart could be left aT the end of the aisle allowing people to more easily move around in the aisle and get the items they needed.

0 comments: